CLICK HERE TO VIEW CURRENT ISSUE

Best of NAMA 2026

Stay Informed
with these

Services
Agri Marketing Update
e-newsletter sent each Monday and Thursday
@AgriMarketing on Twitter
Farm Show Guide
Marketing Services Guide
Books:

National Agri-Marketing Association
NAMA Website
Upcoming Events
Chapters
Agri-Marketing Conf
Best of NAMA 2025










SYNGNETA SUES GRAIN EXPORTING COMPANIES IN CORN TRAIT DISPUTE
Dow Jones reports:

Syngenta AG sued several grain-trading firms over losses some U.S. farmers say they sustained after China rejected shipments of genetically modified corn, escalating a legal battle over the way biotech seeds are introduced to farm fields.

The lawsuit, filed late Thursday in U.S. District Court in Kansas, stems from a legal dispute that arose last year when grain companies and farmers sued Syngenta, arguing the company should compensate them for lost sales and depressed corn prices that they claim arose from the rejected shipments.

The Swiss seed and pesticide giant, which is contesting those allegations, argued in the new lawsuit that big grain merchants, including Cargill Inc. and Archer Daniels Midland Co., should be on the hook for losses that crop producers say they are due in the matter.

"We don't think there is any liability here, but to the extent there is, at a minimum, the lion's share of the duty falls on the grain trade," said Michael Jones, a lawyer for Kirkland & Ellis LLP representing Syngenta in the matter.

A Cargill spokesman said that "Syngenta's commercialization practices and conduct are responsible for the industry's damages." A spokeswoman for ADM declined to comment, citing pending litigation.

Syngenta in 2011 began selling a new variety of biotech corn seeds--called Viptera and engineered to resist pests--to farmers in the U.S., Argentina and Brazil after those governments granted approval for its cultivation. In late 2013, Chinese officials began turning away shipments of U.S. corn bound for Chinese ports after detecting the Syngenta strain, which the country had yet to approve for import.

Last year, Cargill sued Syngenta over the corn, alleging that Syngenta's decision to market the seeds without first securing Chinese import approval cost the Minnesota-based agribusiness $90 million when Beijing began rejecting corn shipments.

Other grain shippers, including ADM, also sued Syngenta. The grain firms' cases touched off a wave of lawsuits filed by farmers across the country, who argued that they too lost money because China's rejections of U.S. corn shipments depressed the overall price of corn by closing off a key market.

Syngenta has defended its move to sell the seeds, saying it followed the law, was fully transparent and provided to farmers a valuable new tool for defending their crops against insect pests.

The judge for the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, who is handling the farmers' lawsuits, in September ruled that the farmers can bring legal claims against a seed company over its duty to ensure that any biotech seeds don't damage other players in the "interconnected" U.S. corn supply chain.

That ruling allowed the farmers' case against Syngenta to move forward. But Syngenta's new lawsuit argues that it also places responsibility on the grain traders, as participants in the grain market, to shield farmers and other players against the same potential economic damage that could arise if shipments are rejected for containing unapproved biotech traits.

If the judge determines the farmers are due damages, Syngenta's lawsuit argues that Cargill, ADM and two smaller grain companies should bear some or all of the liability. Syngenta could add additional grain companies to the lawsuit, Mr. Jones said.


Search News & Articles








Proudly associated with:
Ag Media Council Canadian Agri-food Marketers Alliance National Agri-Marketing Association National Association of Farm Broadcasters
Agricultural Relations Council Agricultural Communicators Network Livestock Publications Council
All content © 2026, Henderson Communications LLC. | User Agreement